Measuring SEO Success: Key Metrics for Small Business Owners
How To Measure SEO Success: Metrics for Small Businesses

Which SEO Metrics Really Matter?
Open any SEO tool right now and you’ll be faced with an army of technical terms, complex infographics, and lengthy lists that’ll have you panicking and gasping for air. It’s confusing, we know. So let’s see which metrics should really matter to your small business depending on your goals.
Do you wish to sell more? Then track your Conversions, E-commerce Conversion Rate, and Organic Sales.
Do you wish to be more known among your local audience? Then track your local Keyword Rankings, Organic Traffic (and its sources), and Local Rankings.
Do you wish to lower your marketing spending? Then track your Organic Traffic Share, Cost-per-Acquisition (CPA) for Organic Traffic, and Return on Investment (ROI) for SEO.
Do you wish to increase conversions? Then check your Overall Conversion Rate, Landing Page Conversion Rates, and Goal Completions in Analytics.
6 SEO Success Metrics
Keyword Rankings
Often the most straightforward (and easiest) SEO metric to track is your keywords’ rankings. Keyword rankings show what position you appear on Google when someone searches for a specific term.
Keyword research is a great tool to find ranking opportunities with terms that have a higher potential of earning organic traffic for your website.
If you’ve been putting any effort into ranking for certain keyword groups, check your progress by analyzing how much traffic target keywords get. Naturally, this requires you to list your target keywords and mark down their rankings at least once a month. After all, how else would you be able to see progress?
Conversion Rate
A conversion rate is the percentage of visitors who take a desired action on your website. This action can be anything from buying a product or service to completing a contact form or sharing your content on social channels.
Depending on the number of visitors and the percentage of them that actually take the desired action, your conversion rate (CR) can change.
Here’s how to calculate the conversion rate:
- Define your desired action (conversion).
- Track the number of visitors who complete that action during a specific timeframe (e.g., month).
- Divide the number of conversions by the total number of website visitors in the same timeframe.
- Multiply the result by 100 to express it as a percentage.

Google Analytics Report of elegantlysetinstone.com
Organic Traffic Share
Organic traffic share is the percentage of your total website traffic that comes from organic search results. In other words, it shows how much of your website’s audience you’re attracting for free through SEO efforts, compared to visitors arriving from paid advertising, social media, or other channels.
Here’s how to calculate it:
- Divide the number of visitors from organic search by your total website traffic.
- Multiply the result by 100 to express it as a percentage.
The higher your organic traffic share is, the more successful your SEO strategy is in driving your website’s traffic.
Cost-per-Acquisition (CPA) for Organic Traffic
Cost-per-acquisition (CPA) is more of a marketing metric that shows how much it costs on average to acquire a customer through a specific channel. In this case, we’re focusing on organic traffic, so the CPA for organic traffic tells you how much you’re “spending” (through SEO efforts) to acquire a customer who visits your website organically.
Here’s the formula:
CPA (Organic Traffic) = Total SEO Cost / Number of Conversions from Organic Traffic.
- Total SEO Cost: This can include expenses for SEO tools, content creation, and any other SEO-related activities.
- Conversions: These are website visitors who take a desired action, such as making a purchase or signing up for a newsletter.
A lower CPA for organic traffic is ideal. This means your SEO efforts are efficiently generating conversions at a cost-effective rate.
Return on Investment (ROI) for SEO
Return on investment (ROI) is one of the most important metrics to measure how beneficial your SEO efforts have been so far. Finding your ROI helps you understand how much return you’re getting on your SEO investment, and we recommend calculating this metric after at least a few months have passed since you’ve started your SEO plan.
Here’s a simple way to calculate ROI:
ROI (SEO) = (Revenue from Organic Traffic – SEO Cost) / SEO Cost * 100%
- Revenue from Organic Traffic: Isolate the revenue generated from website visitors who came through organic search.
- SEO Cost: Similar to CPA, factor in all your SEO-related expenses.
The higher the ROI, the more profitable your SEO efforts are.

Local Rankings
Local rankings, particularly your position in the coveted Google Maps results section (the local pack), determine how successful you are at grabbing local customers’ attention. If you rank well in your local area, you’ll have a much higher chance of being found by your potential audience.
You can use tools like Local Falcon to measure your Share of Local Voice (SoLV) score and see how you’re doing in your area.
Here are some key tactics and tools to elevate your local search ranking:
Claim Your Google Business Profile: A Google business profile allows you to manage your business listing on Google Search and Maps.
Harness the Power of Reviews: Encourage satisfied customers to leave positive reviews on Google My Business and other relevant platforms. Online reviews significantly influence customer decisions.
NAP Consistency is King: NAP stands for Name, Address, and Phone number. Remember it and make sure the information is consistent and accurate across all online directories and listings.
Location Pages: If you have brick-and-mortar locations, create dedicated location pages on your website. Include details like address, contact information, working hours, and unique selling points for each location.
Local Content Creation: Craft content meant for your local audience specifically. This could be blogs about local events, guides relevant to your area, or community-focused posts.
Get Started!
Remember, SEO isn’t a one-size-fits-all strategy. By understanding and tracking the metrics we discussed, you can tailor your SEO approach to achieve your specific goals, whether it’s driving more sales, boosting brand awareness, lowering marketing spend, or increasing conversions.
Momentum will tailor a data-driven strategy and an ongoing optimization plan so you can watch your small business grow and those SEO metrics hitting the roof. Get a free SEO demo from us today!